Skip to main content

Benefit Cosmetics they're Real! Lengthening Mascara Review

I received a free sample of Benefit they're Real! Mascara at Ulta. I don't use Benefit products and I will tell you why later in this post. It's not that I think they are bad products. It's that I don't agree with their policies. But, I thought let me try this sample that was given to me so that you can read the review and learn a bit about Benefit Cosmetics. 
benefit they're mascara
Benefit they're Real! Lengthening Mascara claims that it lengthens, curls, volumizes, lifts and separates your lashes. It has a specially designed brush to bring out all of your lashes. Does it live up to the claims?

The Review 
They're Real! has one of those scary mascara brushes with lots of spiky bristles. The kind of mascara wand that makes me feel like I'm going to poke my eye. I know the spiky bristles are meant to separate the lashes and bring out every little lash, but they make me nervous! I find the applicator similar to the Hello Lashes applicator.
(Read my Hello Lashes review)

benefit they're mascara brush
Anyway, the mascara goes on smoothly and the brush does help you get all the lashes covered. It is nice and black. It looks good on my lashes with one coat, but it doesn't do much lengthening or curling. The second coat seems add volume but it starts to clump a bit and I see it's beginning to give me that spider lash look that I really don't care for. I would not put a third coat on. It didn't smudge or smear, but I did have a little bit of flaking by the end of the day. It was a bit messy during removal. It leaves serious raccoon eyes if you try to remove it in the shower. An eye makeup remover definitely needed. It's a okay mascara but it just doesn't live up to the hype for me.
Here is a picture of my lashes with 2 coats of they're Real! Mascara.benefit they're mascara on lashes
Now, let's get to why I don't use Benefit Cosmetics. I like to use cosmetic products that are not tested on animals. Why should an animal suffer, afraid in a cage, in a lab, so that I can look more beautiful? There are plenty of fabulous brands that don't test on animals. I use those brands. 
Benefit wants you to believe that they do not test their products on animals. This is what it says on their website:
Does Benefit Cosmetics test on animals? 
"Benefit does not test our products on animals.
Since 1989, the Perfumes & Cosmetics companies of LVMH group
 (including Benefit Cosmetics) have not performed any tests on
 animals for our products - this was implemented long before the
 2013 official ban set by the European Union.

We are deeply committed to the elimination of animal testing. We’re
playing a leading role in developing alternative methods through
our support of the “Fund for Alternatives to Animal Testing” in the 
United States. We also actively participate in validation studies of
new alternative tests in the framework of the European cosmetics 
association, Cosmetics Europe. We are one of only a few companies
to have invested in creating our own internal department to test raw 
materials and ingredients to further ensure the quality of our 
products and the satisfaction of our customers, which is our top

We are hopeful that alternative testing methods will be adopted 
worldwide and we will see an end to animal testing."

Other LVMH group brands include Parfums Christian Dior, Parfums
 Givenchy and Guerlain, Fresh and Make Up For Ever.

But Benefit is on the Companies that do test on 

Animals lists.

PETA says Benefit tests on animals and is not observing a 
moratorium. Benefit is not on the Leaping Bunny list. And
Benefit is on the beautypedia Brands that do test on animals

So what is going on? 

Well, it seems Benefit Cosmetics is sold by Sephora in China

China requires animal testing of cosmetic products.

Therefore, Benefit Cosmetics tests on animals. 

It's the same thing with the Estee Lauder Group, The L'Oreal
Group and Revlon. 

The US does not require animal testing but China does require 

Any company selling their products in China is doing animal
testing. That's it.

Why do these companies have to be greedy and go against
what they say they believe in (being "deeply committed to the
elimination of animal testing") to sell in countries that require
animal testing. They have no integrity. 

I wonder what would happen if all of us makeup consumers
here in the US stopped buying makeup tested on animals. 
That would be a significant loss of income for those

It is a dreamof mine that people would realize the horror of 
animal testing and band together to force these big companies
to stop doing it.

If you don't like that some companies test on animals, let those
companies know. Go to their websites. Go to the Contact Us
page and send them an email letting them know that you
won't buy their products because they are tested on animals.

I did reach out to Benefit with an email asking why it states on
their website that they don't test on animals yet they are on
the companies that do test on animals. Their answer was this:

"Hi Jill, 

Thank you for taking the time to write to us. Unfortunately, we will have to research this particular inquiry a little bit further. Don’t worry! We will respond with more information as soon as possible. Thank you for your patience!' 

I will post the response when I get it. Here is the response:

Hi Jill,

Thank you for your patience while we escalated this inquiry to our Customer Care
Manager. Although Benefit is not PETA/Leaping Bunny certified, we do not test
our products on animals and we are deeply committed and actively working to
promote the development, validation and recognition of non-animal test methods.
We strictly control our cosmetic products throughout the supply chain to the
highest ethical and legal standards.

Love & Lipstick,


Benefit Cosmetics Customer Care"

I mentioned earlier, there are many fabulous brands that are not 
tested on animals, Urban Decay, Too Faced, Lorac, It Cosmetics, 
Tarte, and NYX are a few.

Go to the following sites to check for more brands that are not tested on animals:
Have a Beautiful Day!

Licensed Cosmetologist, Esthetician, Makeup Artist

PS: Thanks for using my amazon & direct linksπŸ’‹
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases at no cost to you. That keeps my blog running and supports the care of animals in need!😸


Popular posts from this blog

White Bumps Under Eyes: Milia

Have you noticed that you have little white looking bumps under your eyes? Some people call it chicken skin because the bumps look like plucked chicken skin. πŸ” Most likely those little white bumps are milia. They can feel hard or pearly. These bumps are not acne. Milia can occur when dead skin cells become trapped beneath the outer layer of skin. Keratin becomes trapped and builds up. A small benign cyst can form which is the milia. It's a cyst!?! Don't let that word scare you. They are harmless, but unwanted bumps.  They can occur on any area of the skin that tends to be on the dry side. They cannot be squeezed out like a blackhead or pimple because they have no opening. A layer of skin covers them. A hole must be created in them using a needle, then they can be extracted out. Read more about blackhead, whiteheads and blind pimples This is a common problem for the under-eye area. It is a dry, delicate area of the skin. I see it a lot on my clients. Heavy products


This post is all about dermatofibromas and some remedies to help make them look better and ways hide them. It includes my Amazon Affiliate Links to help you find the products I talk about. Q. I have this brown bump on my leg that won't go away. What can I do about it? A. It could be a dermatofibroma. I see them often on my leg waxing clients. A dermatofibroma is a tan to brown benign raised bump more common in women than men and occur commonly on the legs. The bump feels hard under the skin and can be itchy, tender and easily irritated. A doctor will tell you not to worry about it because it's benign, but it's kind of ugly! Dermatofibromas are also called Benign Fibrous Histiocytomas. They are the result of some sort of injury to the skin such as an ingrown hair or a bug bite.  Be careful when shaving because a dermatofibroma may bleed and become sore if nicked. Don't think you can get rid of it by shaving it off. It will be an awful looking sore and will j

Dermatofibroma on Leg

A Dermatofibroma is an unsightly brown or red bump that is very common on the legs. They are also called Benign Fibrous Histiocytomas and are more common in women than men. They can hurt, itch and become inflamed easily. They are the result of some sort of injury to the skin such as an ingrown hair or a bug bite.  I have tried lots of home remedies on my dermatofibroma. Some help it look better than others but the ugly thing is still there! Read more about dermatofibroma remedies. There is only one way to remove it for It must be surgically excised out. A dermatofibroma goes deep into the skin. It will only grow back if it is cut off of the skin at surface level. The problem with the removal is it leaves a long scar that is about 2 inches or so long. It has to be done that way to be able to sew the skin back together so it is smooth and not puckery. Here is a picture of a scar from the removal of a dermatofibroma. This scar was also treated with a laser to imp